Sanjay's Rugby World

The fourth week of the Currie Cup for 2009 allows sides to almost cement semi-final spots.

At an early stage of the competition, the likely semi-final contenders have already taken shape. My picks were spot on last week except for the Bulls losing to the Sharks, but that was made more in hope than confidence.

I’m picking semi-final spots to go to the Bulls, Sharks, Western Province and either the Lions or Griquas. Griquas are building a valuable points buffer, but the Lions are only going to get better as the season goes on. If the Cheetahs lose this weekend, in my opinion their semi-final hopes are gone for 2009.

Lions v Griquas

A tough game to call, and vital in determining who will get into the 4th semi-final spot. As good as Griquas have played this year, at Ellis Park, I’m picking the resurgent Lions to come away with the win.

The Lions will suffer if Jano Vermaak doesn’t take the field, but they have a forward pack that can take Griquas on, and then use the likes of Earl Rose to make something of decent quality ball.

Lions by 10.

Western Province v Platinum Leopards

The Leopards are unlikely to win a match, and Western Province are starting to play quite nicely. They’ll be boosted by some returns from injury, noteably Duane Vermeulen.

I expect a close beginning, before Western Province gain the upper hand and run away with the second half.

Western Province by 23.

Free State Cheetahs v Sharks

Naka Drotske believes the desperation factor will help the Cheetahs. That hasn’t helped them all year. Despite the Sharks poor record in Bloemfontein, especially in recent times, I expect the trend to be reversed.

The musical chairs Nake Drotske is playing with Springbok wing Jongi Nokwe, shows the lack of direction from the Free State coaching staff, and that can hardly be helping the players. The Sharks are a settled squad and will benefit from having Argentinian Juan Martin Hernandez, in what is already a settled side.

Sharks by 10.

Blue Bulls v Boland

The Blue Bulls have had a tough start to the 2009 Currie Cup, and have been strongly affected by Springbok duty and injuries. They’ll welcome the chance to have an easy game at Loftus Versfeld against the Boland Kavaliers.

The strength of the Bulls so far this year has been the depth, settled playing pattern and confidence of the squad. If they get a roll happening they’ll rack up plenty of points. The 5 points will certainly strengthen their log position and keep them in touch for a home semi-final.

Blue Bulls by 50.

Rugby’s greatest rivals, the Springboks and the All Blacks go at it again in Durban.

This Tri-nations match takes on huge significance in that it may establish a new era in this great rivalry. Last week saw the Springboks beat the All Blacks in Bloemfontein, to move to number 1 in the IRB rankings. The All Blacks will be gutted and pride themselves on being the dominant force in World rugby, at least between World Cups anyway!

The Springboks and All Blacks have named largely unchanged sides from Bloemfontein for their 77th clash.

The Springboks have replaced Ruan Pienaar with Morne Steyn in what I think is a good move, and gives the side a much greater ability to convert pressure into points, through it’s goalkicking. And don’t be surprised to see a few drop-goal attempts, as I think the Springboks try this to keep the scoreboard ticking over.

The All Blacks have replaced Neemia Tialata with the little known Owen Franks. There is never a weak All Black prop however, and whilst many from both countries are talking up his ability, he should be respected but not over-awed. The other change sees Brendon Leonard swapping with Jimmy Cowan, in a move that should give the All Blacks better kicking strength from the base of the scrum/ruck.

This Springbok side has evolved into a more complete side than the one that won the Rugby world cup in 2007.

The forward pack is dominant, and is very strong in the set-pieces. The lineout is extremely solid on Springbok ball, but it’s the ability to uncrack the code of the opposition that will see the All Black lineout come under extreme pressure. In Bloemfontein we did this brilliantly, and try as they might to fix it, Victor Matfield should be good enough to demolish it again.

The Springbok pack at the breakdown works well as a unit, and whilst the two sides always have a great go at each other, I don’t believe Richie McCaw has enough back up to compete on his own. In Durban, expect to see Heinrich Brussow once again benefit from having Bakkies Botha, Bismarck du Plessis and Juan Smith doing the hard yards. this should allow Superman Spies to be faster than a speeding All Black, and provide even more opportunities than he created in Bloemfontein, as he appears to be hitting top form once again.

Whilst the All Black backline looked dangerous last week, if they are once again starved of the possession, they can’t hurt the Springboks. Meanwhile I expect Fourie du Preez to lift his clearances and get this Springbok backline going more fluently than they did in Bloemfontein, to create further opportunities for the Boks. I’m picking Francois Steyn to be more prominent hitting the backline and bringing the Springbok back three into play.

For the All Blacks to win, they’ll have to show their characteristic tenacity, and use their scrum to dominate. If they get outplayed in the forwards again, any chance they get through the backs will need to be taken with clinical precision. But if the Springboks make better use of their chances, it could result in a knockout blow much earlier than was the case last week.

What impresses me the most with this Springbok side is their mental shift. Starting with the coach Peter de Villiers, he appears to be learning the lessons that the past 15 months have thrown at him and emerging a better coach for it. However it’s hearing players like Victor Matfield, talking about wanting more trophies, more Tri-nations, more dominance that excites me most.

Too often in the past the Springboks have appeared to give the All Blacks too much respect and lacked the self-belief to win. 2 Super 14 titles in the last 3 years, a second Rugby World Cup and a core group of experienced hardened professionals sees this Springbok side hungry to start establishing World dominance. Whilst some of our players will inevitably leave for the greater monetary rewards overseas, it guys like Morne Steyn who speaks of wanting to play 50 tests for the Springboks, that epitomises the heartbeat of a proud and hungry Springbok. At the same time it is leading to the breakdown of the All Black aura, that may just see this rivalry enter a new phase…one where we slowly even up the score again.

I’m excited, I’m predicting a Springbok win by 10 and I’m looking forward to seeing this Springbok side move to a new level…

The All Blacks

1. Tony Woodcock
2. Andrew Hore
3. Owen Franks
4. Brad Thorn
5. Isaac Ross
6. Jerome Kaino
7. Richie McCaw (c)
8. Rodney So’oialo
9. Jimmy Cowan
10. Stephen Donald
11. Sitiveni Sivivatu
12. Ma’a Nonu
13. Conrad Smith
14. Joe Rokocoko
15. Mils Muliaina

16. Keven Mealamu
17. John Afoa
18. Jason Eaton
19. Kieran Read
20. Piri Weepu
21. Luke McAlister
22. Cory Jane

The Springboks

1. Beast Mtawarira
2. Bismarck du Plessis
3. John Smit (c)
4. Bakkies Botha
5. Victor Matfield
6. Heinrich Brussow
7. Juan Smith
8. Pierre Spies
9. Fouire du Preez
10. Morne Steyn
11. Bryan Habana
12. Jean de Villiers
13. Jaque Fourie
14. JP Pietersen
15. Frans Steyn

16. Chiliboy Ralepelle
17. Jannie du Plessis
18. Danie Rossouw
19. Andries Bekker
20. Ricky Januarie
21. Adi Jacobs
22. Wynand Olivier

It’s a largely unchanged Springbok side from the one that beat the All Blacks in Bloemfontein last weekend. The forward pack is unchanged with just one change on the bench, Andries Bekker coming in for Ryan Kankowski. Bekker seems to be a favourite amongst the coaching staff, and may replace Bakkies Botha, in which case who does Danie Rousouw come on for. You can’t replace victor Matfield. Can you? The only logical scenario I could see would be to put on Danie Rousouw for Juan Smith. 

In the backline, the addition of Morne Steyn gives us greater goalkicking reliability, but may rob us of Ruan Pienaar’s silky running skills. I’d have preferred an outside back as opposed to having two centres on the bench.

Still it’s a run on side that can and is expected to do the damage to the All Blacks. If we gain the forward momentum like we did in Bloemfontein, some of the reserves may be able to come on and wreak a bit of havoc that we need to get a 4 try bonus point. it could be crucial at the end of the competition.

1995, One team, One country. The Springboks. World Champions

The 1995 Rugby World Cup final against the All Blacks was the most important day in South African rugby history. It was a momentous day, inspired from above, and the effect on our great nation was unbelievable.

Throughout the tournament South Africa were guided by a higher power, as we beat many of the major rugby nations. Australia, France finally the All Blacks.

To see Nelson Mandela in the Springbok jersey, handing over the William Webb Ellis trophy to Springbok captain was an unbelievable occassion in South African history. Madiba thanked Francois Pienaar for his contribution, but we are all indebted to the great man for his role in rescuing South Africa.

It made one proud to be South African. It showed how great our nation can be. How the colour lines can be broken…not black, not white – just dynamite!

The 1995 Rugby World Cup, where the Springboks defied the odds and became the World Champions, is to be made into a feature film. Watching this short clip brings back memories of that great day.

It recreates tears of joy, ignites the pride and passion of South Africans, and above all gives us the hope that the South Africa we all strive for can become our reality.

I was reasonably happy with the Springboks performance in beating the All Blacks 28-19 in Bloemfontein.

We showed we have the blueprint to beat any rugby side in the world. If we establish forward dominance, it doesn’t matter what the opposition do.

Here is my review of the game:

This was an all around team effort, with few standout players. The forward pack functioned superbly as a unit, creating enormous pressure on the All Blacks. Deserved their victory, but perhaps let down by some poor goal kicking from Ruan Pienaar in the first half, when we could have put the game beyond doubt.

Springbok Player ratings:

1. The Beast Mtawarira – 6

Tackled strongly, and was solid in the scrums. Had one or two good runs, but is really a man we need a bit more go forward from. Could become more consistent in this area to become a great like Os du Randt.

2. Bismarck du Plessis – 8

A good performance from Bismarck du Plessis all around the field. Was strong at the rucks, carrying the ball and behaves like an extra loose forward at times. Missed one crucial lineout throw in the second half, and strangely seemed  to struggle to hear the lineout calls throughout the match! His discipline was much better in this game.

3. John Smit – 7

Leads the side brilliantly. Always composed and is becoming one of the great Springbok captains. Performed adequately in the scrums and is always willing to hit the ball up. Made one handling error, but that is a rarity these days.

4. Bakkies Botha – 7

Brings the hard edge to the pack, and his work and presence at the rucks is invaluable. Made one important tackle and slowed down at the ruck in the second half and had an all round valuable contribution.

5. Victor Matfield – 8

The best lineout forward in the world. Safe as houses on our own ball, but his value is in disrupting the opposition ball, and he set the tone for this on the All Blacks first lineout. Doesn’t usually make handling errors, and could have created space for Habana in the first half but had the ball knocked out when he had it in one hand.

6. Heinrich Brussow – 8

Shows the value of having a true opensider in the Springbok side. May not have won every ruck, but simply competing and having a presence is vital and slows the opposition ball down. Great work rate and his low centre of gravity helped create a couple of vital turnovers.

7. Juan Smith – 8

Gets through an enormous amount of work, on defence and attack. Made some great runs, some solid hits and was johnny on the spot when Spies hacked ahead to put Jacque Fourie away for the match-winning try.

8. Pierre Spies – 7

Much improved from the Lions series. Had some great runs with ball in hand, and always dragged in 2 defenders. It was his pace that created Jaque Fourie’s try. He has sensational speed for a big man. Was strong in defence and gets through a lot of work that goes unrecognised.

9. Fourie Du Preez – 7

His kicking was spot on from the base of the ruck/scrum. Could have kicked a bit more and created more lineouts. A couple of times he created pressure on himself by not clearing the ball from the base of the ruck fast enough. Just needs to ensure he controls the tempo of the game a little more.

10. Ruan Pienaar – 5

Missed too many valuable points on offer with poor kicking. He may have hit the post twice, but at this level it’s not good enough. Was good in general play and general field kicking though, and let’s hope his injury is not too serious as he is steadily getting better. Being injured creates problems in terms of flyhalf cover too.

11. Bryan Habana – 6

Play never went his way. But also didn’t work hard enough off the ball. Contested the high balls well, but needs to try and reclaim more and create chances for his side.

12. Jean de Villiers – 6

Relished the physicality of the game, and perhaps overdid it a bit, instead of trying to get his backs away. Got one trademark interception and is solid for the Boks in midfield. His injury may seem him out for the rest of the season, and that could affect the Springboks dearly.

13. Jacque Fourie – 7

Is solid in all aspects of play, but perhaps isn’t able to put his outside backs away. Has become a deadly finisher over the last 12 months, and has scored some crucial tries for the Boks.

14. JP Pietersen – 7

Barely touched the ball all game. Made an important tackle in the first half when the All Blacks were attacking down his side, and over the last couple of years has made some vital tackles which go unrecognised. His defence is excellent, but as he showed against the British and Irish Lions, he can be a great threat on attack too. The Springboks need to use him more.

15. Frans Steyn – 6

Started off with a  very important long range penalty. Was strong running at the All Black line but also took some poor options and gifted the ball back to the All Blacks on occasion. Needs to learn to hit the line as a fullback, and worryingly again was moving backwards in defence when Conrad Smith scored. He would have been unable to do anything, but someone on the Springbok coaching staff needs to address this.

16. Chiliboy Ralepelle -

Not on long enough to make a telling contribution

17. Jannie du Plessis – 6

Came on temporarily for John Smit. Did his job.

18. Danie Rousouw – 6

Didn’t make a noticeable impact when he came on, but remains a good sub to have on the bench.

19. Ryan Kankowski -

Was not needed. Thankfully.

20. Ricky Januarie – 6

Not sure why he was brought on with 5 minutes to play. I’d have kept the best halfback in the world on the field, not taken an unnecessary gamble. Did his job.

21. Morne Steyn – 7

Kicked the points for the Springboks when they mattered, only missing a difficult effort from the sideline. Missed the tackle on Conrad Smith that led to the All Blacks try, but that is not a usual occurrence. Will probably start in Durban if Pienaar is not 100%.

22. Wynand Olivier – 6

On for the last 12 minutes or so, and made a good contribution when Spies picked one up off the base of the scrum. Will probably start in Durban unless the Springbok coaching staff gamble on playing Adi Jacobs at 12.

The Springboks ran out deserved winners over the All Blacks 28-19 in Bloemfontein.

This was an important victory for the the Springboks in this years tri-nations as points at home are crucial to staying in this competition. Whilst they dominated most aspects of play, and created enormous amounts of pressure on the All Blacks, the result was only sealed in the last couple of minutes.

Both sides started off with a ferocious intensity, that saw the All Blacks gain a couple of penalties at the breakdown. Stephen Donald nailed his first attempt to give the All Blacks a 3-0 lead. Francois Steyn hit back almost immediately with a long range penalty goal after the All Blacks were caught offside.

From then on, the Springbok pack played superbly as a unit. They disrupted the All Black lineout, contested each breakdown, and simply forced the All Blacks into coughing up possession or giving away penalties due to immense pressure. Ruan Pienaar hit the post twice with penalty attempts, and the All Blacks weren’t made to pay for their indiscretions.

At this stage the All Blacks were having to make plenty of tackles and the Springboks were enjoying a prolonged period of field position deep in All Blacks territory. From a scrum a strong bullocking run from Superman Spies created great go forward, and the ball was swung wide to the left with Ruan Pienaar doubling around after Jean de Villiers went to ground, and he rounded off a well deserved try for the Springboks.  This opened up a 11-3 lead to the Springboks.

Almost immediately Heinrich Brussow created a vital turnover at a ruck in Springbok territory. The ball was passed out to Victor Matfield who had the ball in one hand trying to slip it around his tackler. Had he gotten it left towards Bryan Habana, it’s would’ve been a great try-scoring chance and could’ve blown the game wide open. Instead it was a rare handling error from one of the Springbok greats, and he can be forgiven for that!

Francois Styen kicked another penalty to make it a 14-3 lead, and Ruan Pienaar should have slotted another chance but missed yet again. As the half was ending the All Blacks showed a great willingness to keep the ball alive and were looking extremely dangerous running at the Springboks.

At Halftime the score was Springboks 14 – All Blacks 3

The second half saw Ruan Pienaar replaced by Morne Steyn due to injury which proved a god send. An early penalty to Morne opened up a 17-3 lead to the Springboks, and a mountain for the All Blacks to climb.

But one thing the All Blacks never do is give up, and it’s a Springbok weakness that we simply don’t put sides away when we have the chance. We should’ve been up by 20 points, but in the blink of an eye a a great run by Conrad Smith through a weak Morne Steyn tackle saw the lead reduced to 17-10. The All Blacks started to apply the pressure now, running the ball strongly at the Springboks, and making great yardage even though they couldn’t break the line.

Juan Smith was penalised for holding on when he got isolated at a ruck, and Stephen Donald closed the gap to 17-13. With a commanding hold on the game now reduced to a 4 point lead, and the momentum with the All Blacks, this game looked to be slipping away for the Springboks as so many have over the years.

Thankfully the Springboks responded strongly. A series of phases in which the Boks went sideways, saw a penalty awarded to the Springboks. Morne Steyn eased the lead back out to 7, as the Springboks were ahead 20-13.

A poor scrum from the Springboks the All Blacks come through and charge into Springbok territory. A great attacking opportunity was met with fantastic defence and I thought the Boks were unlucky to be pinged when I felt the All Blacks were holding on. In any case Donald closed the gap to 4.

Then Jean de Villiers went off injured, and that may have a dramatic effect on the state of the Tri-nations. He’s the pillar in the Springbok midfield. Wynand Olivier is not in the same class, and playing Adi Jacobs could be a bad move especially as he’d not fully fit.

Then came a great piece of play from Superman Pierre Spies. A ball was spilt by Jason Eaton, and faster than a speeding bullet, Pierre had hacked it ahead. The pace of the big man created too much pressure for Richie McCaw to handle, and Juan Smith was on hand to get the ball to a flying Jacque Fourie who went in at the corner. Just brilliant! Even though Morne Steyn missed the conversion, the game was almost sealed.

But in another twist, a penalty straight away for the All Blacks made it a 6 point gap, and everything to play for. The Springboks then got their hands on the ball and showed their professionalism. The rolling maul, which they used to great effect all game was employed from a lineout just inside their half, and they milked a penalty from Jason Eaton superbly as his frustration saw him come in from offside.

Morne Steyn nailed the kicked to give the Springboks a 28-19 lead. Then we simply controlled possesssion and wound the clock down. I was extremely pleased we didn’t allow them a bonus point as we so often do.

Full time: Springboks 28, All Blacks 19

The Springboks deservedly go back to Number 1 in the IRB ratings, and we get to do this all over again next week in Durban!

The Springboks played well and whilst the margin was only 9, we should’ve put them away by 20 had our kickers been on song. You can check out my Springbok player ratings for this test, although overall it was a great team effort. or watch my video review.

The All Blacks will be naturally disappointed, but probably targeted next weeks clash in Durban as their must win game anyway. They’ll be a lot better having gotten over the jet lag, playing at sea level, and knowing what they have to improve.  It promises to be even bigger!

Springboks v All Blacks – Free State stadium, Bloemfontein

Live Updates

A great atmosphere in Bloemfontein for the start of this game.

1st Min – Great intensity. I thought the All Blacks came into that ruck illegally.

3rd Min – Penalty All Blacks for obstructing the kicker chasing through. What a bulls*#t call. Donald kicks it. All Blacks 3-0.

5th Min – All Blacks penalised at the ruck. Francois Steyn kicks over 50m! 3-3.

10th Min – Head high tackle from So’ialo on Bismarck du Plessis. Penalty kicked by Ruan Pienaar but hits the post.

13th Min – Brendon Leonard offside after Nonu spills the ball. Penalty Boks! Hits the post again!

14th Min – Sloppy play from Francois Steyn. Gives the All Blacks a penelty chance. Missed it!

17th Min – Another penalty to the Springboks for pulling down the maul. That one may have been a bit harsh in my view, but we’ll take another shot. Ruan Pienaar slots it. Boks 6-3!

25th Min – Try Ruan Pienaar finishes off a sustained period of Springbok pressure on the All Black line. Pienaar misses his conversion. Springboks 11-3.

28th Min – Damn, Matfield spills it when he could’ve released Habana down the flank.

31st Min – Pienaar misses a drop attempt.

32nd Min – Steyn kicks a penalty for the All Blacks being offside, Springboks ahead 14-3.

38th Min – Penalty Boks! Great tackle from Bakkies. Pienaar misses again. Springboks 14-3.

40th Min – All Blacks show a great willingness to try and score but make an error and Brussow kicks it to touch.

Halftime – Springboks 14 All Blacks 3

It’s been a gripping test match. The Springboks have piled on the pressure and Pienaar has missed some vital points for the Springboks. It would’ve given the Springboks a great cushion. As it stands an 11 point lead is definitely not safe.Too many penalties robbed the game of any real momentum.

Morne Steyn is stripped and looks set to come out for the second half. His goalkicking could be crucial.

42nd Min – Magic Morne kicks one over for the All Blacks being offside. Springboks 17-3.

46th Min – Try to Conrad Smith. Morne Steyn missed a vital tackle there. Donald converts and now it’s a 7 point ball game. Springboks 17-10.

51st Min – Penalty All Blacks. McCaw made a great turnover on Juan Smith who was isolated. Bakkies penalised at the ensuing ruck. Donald kicks the penalty. Springboks 17-13.

54th Min – Great up and under from du Preez. Chance for the Boks now as the All Blacks knocked it on.

56th Min – Sustained pressure from the Springboks. Didn’t make a lot of headway and the ensuing penalty from the ruck will be taken gladly. Morne Steyn kicks it. Springboks 20-13.

63rd Min – Good continuity from the All Blacks. Resulted from a poor scrum from the Springboks. After numerous phases the All Blacks win a penalty. I thought it was a bit harsh, All Blacks held onto the ball and Springboks were on their feet. Donald kicks it. Springboks ahead 20-16.

68th Min – de Villiers is injured. I’d say that is his season over. Wynand Olivier comes on, and Rousouw replaces Bakkies.

72nd Min – Spies! What pace, his chasing of a loose kick created the pressure, and Smith gathers the loose ball, and puts Jacque Fourie away in the corner! Could be game over, but a crucial bonus point still at stake.

Morne Steyn can’t convert from the sideline. Springboks 25-16.

74th Min – Penalty for the All Blacks. Kickable and gives them a chance to get right back into the game. Silly stuff from the Springboks. Stephen Donald kicks it. Springboks ahead 25-19.

77th Min – Springboks maul it up and milk a penalty. On the halfway line and Morne Steyn will try and seal it. Good boy! He’s got it. Springboks ahead now 28-19.

79th Min – Springbok scrum. Just have to wind the clock down now, and ensure no bonus point for the All Blacks.

8oth Min – It’s all over! Springboks win 28-19!

Full time: Springboks 28 All Blacks 19

The Springboks run out deserved winners, scoring 2 tries to 1. It was close in the end, when poor goalkicking in the first half kept the All Blacks in the game. I’m glad we stopped them getting a bonus point though.

Man of the match: Heinrich Brussow. probably a fair pick, he did well at the breakdown.

The third week of the Currie Cup for 2009 sees the chance for a pecking order to be established.

Whilst it is still early days in the competition, vital log points are being won and lost in crucial exchanges that will have a massive impact by the time the log points need to be tallied up. At this stage it looks like the Bulls, Sharks, Western Province and Griquas might contest the semis.

Sharks v Bulls

The Bulls have to travel down to Durban for a tough game at Kings Park. Compounded with having to do without their Springboks, the Bulls also a number of vital injuries, and weren’t helped when Wynand Olivier was called into the Springboks as cover. However this Bulls side is more than just their Boks, and these youngsters will equip themselves well against a Sharks side that still has plenty of grunt.

Both sides lack for experience at flyhalf, and this is where the prodigiously talented Francois Brummer can make a name for himself. He played well last week, and needs to control this Bulls side around the field. The Sharks meanwhile have a steady flyhalf in Monty Drumond, but don’t expect him to do anything spectacular.

This game should be close, and if the Bulls can sneak home they will almost certainly be assured of a semi-final spot, whereas a loss brings them right down into the pack and plenty to fight for.

Bulls by 6.

Western Province v Free State Cheetahs

The Cheetahs brought their Super 14 experience with them and shown they know how to sew up the bottom of the table! They face the very real danger of seeing their semi-final hopes slipping slowly from away from them unless they can win in Capetown. Western Province have been playing quite well, with a bunch of youngsters who are injecting real enthusiasm into their side. Add to that the hard edge someone like Chris Jack brings to their pack and they being ultra competitive.

I fear we won’t see the Cheetahs make the semi-finals this year, and Western Province to win this one by 10.

Griquas v Boland

Boland have made plenty of changes, including dropping their captain. It’s a recipe for disaster and shows they are clutching at straws, rather than progressively building throughout the Currie Cup. Griquas meanwhile are playing nicely. They’re picking up valuable bonus points, and simply need a couple of scalps against the “bigger unions” to seriously contest for a semi-final spot.

Griquas by 21.

Platinum Leopards v Lions

The Leopards need to enjoy their time in the Currie Cup, because it won’t last for that long. They have some good players, but will be lucky to win a game. The Lions seem to be on the improve and will look for their first win, but more importantly to continue to make strides in their development and playing pattern.

Lions by 21.

Rugby’s greatest rivals, the Springboks and the All Blacks are set for a titanic showdown in Bloemfontein.

At stake are vital IRB ratings points to see who deserves the number 1 spot in World rugby, as well as the small matter of Tri-nations points.
Currently the IRB rankings are as follows:
1. All Blacks 90.95
2. South Africa 89.45

The Springboks are on a quest. They are the current World Champions and have just beaten the British and Irish Lions. There are no bigger prizes left to accomplish, but they are determined to reclaim their number 1 ranking and the Tri-nations from the All Blacks. Both sides have plenty to prove, and come into this fixture without having played their best rugby so far this season.

The Springboks and All Blacks have named their sides for what will be the 76th clash between the 2 old enemies of rugby.

The All Blacks lacked a bit of mongrel in their pack against the Aussies last week, and would best be described as solid not spectacular.

They have a solid front row, but won’t demolish any scrums. Their lineout could be the weak point, with Brad Thorn not really a reliable source of ball, much will fall onto the shoulders of rookie Isaac Ross and Jerome Kaino. The Springboks are the premier lineout in World rugby, and poaching genius Victor Matfield will once again look to dominate this aspect of play.

In the loose forwards they present a strong ball carrying trio, but McCaw doesn’t seem to be that vital 1 step quicker than his opponents any more. Against Heinrich Brussouw he will have a tough battle trying to secure the All Blacks turnover possession.

The backline of the All Blacks always has gamebreakers, but lack the polish and try scoring records that the most dangerous All Blacks sides contain. Stephen Donald can be unreliable as goalkicker and his channel may be where the Springboks try to attack through as his defence is not a strong point.

The Springboks have class all over the field, but will look to dominate through the strong forward pack firstly. Set pieces, especially the lineout are massively strong. At altitude they will look to boot the ball out, gain field field position and rely on Victor Matfield to steal balls at will in the lineout.

This will allow the loose trio a chance to get front foot ball and Pierre Spies and Juan Smith need to get over the advantage line to get the backs going. Against the British and Irish Lions, this didn’t happen and the Springboks couldn’t gain any real momentum.

With quality ball it will allow Fourie du Preez and Ruan Pienaar to weave their magic and get this backline going. The midfield pairing of Jean de Villiers and Jacque Fourie will be able to combat anything the All Blacks throw at them, and their solidity in crashing the ball up will allow space for Bryan Habana and JP Pietersen on the flanks. The Springboks showed in the second test against the Lions at Loftus, a willingness to try and get Bryan Habana running onto the ball and I am sure they will persist with that strategy once they have solid runners in the midfield.

I also think the Springbok bench is stronger than the All Blacks, and the influence of Morne Steyn in the last 20 minutes may finally nail the All Blacks once they are left feeling the effects of the altitude. I’m picking the Springboks to come out firing and after getting out to an early lead, the All Blacks will start to work their way back into the game, before the Boks close out the game in the last half hour strongly as the All Blacks start to wilt under the pressure. That’s what I think will happen but I’ll take a Springbok annihilation anytime!

The Springboks

1. Beast Mtawarira
2. Bismarck du Plessis
3. John Smit (c)
4. Bakkies Botha
5. Victor Matfield
6. Heinrich Brussow
7. Juan Smith
8. Pierre Spies
9. Fouire du Preez
10. Ruan Pienaar
11. Bryan Habana
12. Jean de Villiers
13. Jaque Fourie
14. JP Pietersen
15. Frans Steyn

16. Chiliboy Ralepelle
17. Jannie du Plessis
18. Danie Rossouw
19. Ryan Kankowski
20. Ricky Januarie
21. Morne Steyn
22. Wynand Olivier

The All Blacks

1. Tony Woodcock
2. Andrew Hore
3. Neemia Tialata
4. Brad Thorn
5. Isaac Ross
6. Jerome Kaino
7. Richie McCaw (c)
8. Rodney So’oialo
9. Brendon Leonard
10. Stephen Donald
11. Sitiveni Sivivatu
12. Ma’a Nonu
13. Conrad Smith
14. Joe Rokocoko
15. Mils MuliainaSubs:

16. Keven Mealamu
17. Owen Franks
18. Jason Eaton
19. Kieran Read
20. Piri Weepu
21. Luke McAlister
22. Cory Jane

Rugby’s greatest rivals, the Springboks and the All Blacks are set for a titanic showdown in Bloemfontein.

The tri-nations moves from Eden Park, to the City of roses, Bloemfontein, as the Springboks look to finally bloom under Peter de Villiers.

Whilst the All Blacks now lead this epic rivalry 42-30, both teams find themselves in a remarkably similar situation. Both sides have had a loss this season leading up to the tri-nations, and haven’t shown the form expected from the talent available. Both coaches are supposedly safe until the 2011 rugby World Cup, but whichever coach does not hold the Tri-nations at the end of the season will find the thermometer of public pressure from 2 rugby-crazed nations soaring to boiling point.

Graham Henry has had 6 years at the helm so we know what to expect from his All Black sides. But Peter de Villiers remains an enigma, his Springbok sides producing the sublime, the lacklustre, and the ridiculous. With a settled Springbok squad, and a tough series against the British and Irish Lions under their belt we will finally see the mark de Villiers leaves on this Springbok side. There can be no excuses of getting to know the squad, rustiness or politics. He has chosen his squad, worked with them for an extended period, and now is the time to deliver results.

Whilst I sympathise with de Villiers, the Springbok coaching job be lonely and extremely tough, and having to converse in English when your native tongue is Afrikaans isn’t as easy as it sounds, the time has come for results. Results and worthy performances. I’ve been prepared to be the eternal optimist, and view the glass as half-full rather than half-empty. Whilst the report card I gave him for the British and Irish Lions series was not particularly praiseworthy, I hope he has learnt his lessons, can deliver on his promise, and become the coach many of his players do speak highly of. I’m expecting some sizzling Springbok performances, they are definitely overdue!

The All blacks beat the Wallabies 22-16 at Eden Park on Saturday night.

Whilst there were only 6 points in the result, the All Blacks ran out deserved winners after Australia had dominated the opening 15 minutes.

The Wallabies started off by playing running rugby in greasy conditions and stretched the All Blacks out side initially. They capped this off with a well deserved try to Berrick Barnes. They then seemed to find gaps at will in the All Black defence but butchered a try scoring chance with some bad handling.

Against the All Blacks you have to take your chances, and a 10-0 lead was gradually chipped away at through better field position, and greater go-forward from the All Blacks. This resulted in a penalty to Stephen Donald, before McCaw crashed over for a well-worked try where the All Blacks went through several impressive phases.

The second half was an arm wrestle but neither side were able to score any further tries. at 16-16 it was anybody’s game, but Stephen Donald was able to benefit from sustained All Black pressure and 2 more penalty goals.

I was surprised at the lack of go-forward from each side. Someone to really crash over the advantage line, or out wider, someone to make the line break that either team could benefit from. The Aussies look to be a bunch of no name Aussie battlers, whilst the All Blacks always have game breakers who can punish you. however neither side should worry the Springboks if they are on their game.

I look forward to the game in Bloemfontein this weekend, with the All Blacks having a tough task of travelling and playing at altitude.

I just added my rugby website to Rugby Profiler, so check them out too!

The 2009  Tri-Nations promises to be the mostly highly contested tournament to date.

For the first time in its history, the All Blacks are rated third, even though they have won the tournament 9 times out of 13, including the last 4 years in a row. The Australians are rated highly and many believe they will get stronger and stronger under Robbie Deans. And the Springboks are in great shape coming off a successful 2-1 series win over the British and Irish Lions.

The All Blacks

Lost their hold on the Super 14 crown this year, and will be keen not to let another trophy slip from its grasp. Disappointed in their early season tests against the French and Italians.

The All Blacks start the tournament off against Australia at Eden Park, a ground on which they have not lost to the Wallabies in forever. I can’t see the Aussies winning there despite the All Blacks poor recent form. The return of one Richie McCaw will be a boost of immense proportions, and he will be just the spark to add some determination and composure to the All Blacks.

After their first game, the All Blacks face consecutive tests against the Springboks at Bloemontein and Durban. That’s a tough ask, and if they win one of those games it’ll set them up nicely for the second half where they play the Aussies in Sydney, before 2 more games in New Zealand against the Springboks and Wallabies again.

I predict the All Blacks will lose both games in South Africa, and Graham Henry will start to feel the pressure once more. If he selected his sides better, the All Blacks would be extremely formidable, but he seems to have favourites consisting of players that are not rated as highly by the rest of the world. He’ll welcome the return of Dan Carter later in the tournament, but even that won’t save the All Blacks.

Prediction: 2nd

The Wallabies

Many people are predicting great things from this Wallaby side leading up to the Rugby World cup in 2011. I’m not convinced.

This Wallaby side lacks the class and hard edge in the forwards to consistently challenge the All Blacks and Springboks. Whilst they have a class flyhalf in Giteau, the wingers and fullback are not nearly the accomplished players that Burke, Tune and Roff were when the Wallabies were dominant. Whilst many think that Robbie Deans is the saviour of Australian rugby, I don’t believe he can work miracles on a side that simply doesn’t have the raw materials to produce the desired results.

They have a favourable draw with only 1 game in their hoodoo country South Africa, coming at the back of the Springboks playing the All Blacks twice in successive weeks, and then play the Springboks twice at home. However that may not be enough to save a side that is talking a big game, but may not be able to back it up with results. If they get 1 or 2 injuries to key players, they’ll struggle to recover.

Prediction: 3rd

The Springboks

The World Champions have a settled side and the benefit of coming off a tough series against the British and Irish Lions. Have to play their first 3 games in 3 consecutive weeks which is tough, but not as tough as playing games 4-6 in 3 consecutive weeks away from home!

Their biggest weakness in Coach Peter de Villiers. If he gets selection right, employs a game plan that suits the players, and doesn’t mess up the substitutions, this Bok side will be extremely tough to beat. All the Super 14 winning Bulls had a quiet series against the British and Irish Lions, so I’m picking Superman Spies, Fourie du Preez, Victor Matfield, Bakkies Botha and Bryan Habana to produce their magic and provide the catalyst for some sizzling Springbok performances.

Prediction: 1st

The first round of the Currie Cup 2009 indicated how close this year’s competition is going to be.

Whilst I didn’t watch any of the games, the results and reports showed that this year the competition is going to be tight. The traditional powerhouses have been weakened once again by the absence of their Springboks, and this makes the remaining sides more competitive.

Every week, sides are going to be playing tough games, and the usual top five unions (Bulls, Sharks, Lions, Cheetahs, Western Province) must ensure they beat the smaller unions (Griquas, Boland, Platinum Leopards), otherwise at the end of the season they may miss out by 1 or 2 points.

Boland (26) – Platinum Leopards (18)

Boland started strongly and worked their way out to a good lead. However the Leopards showed that they will not lie down for anybody their season and came back strongly in the second half. Boland will be thankful to pick up the points, and this may be crucial to avoid relegation at the end of the season.

Free State (18) – Griquas (28)

A massive upset in round 1. The Cheetahs showed that losing is contagious, and claimed the same position they occupied for the entire Super 14. The Cheetahs had the winning of this game, but like the Super 14, they discovered you need to play for 80 minutes, and finish teams off.

This Griquas side is always tough to beat at home in Kimberly, but they have now demonstrated after their wonderful Vodacom cup win in 2009, they will be a force to be reckoned with. They are well coached by Dawie Theron, but what impresses me most is their desire to win. Attitude goes a long way to winning games, and it is what makes the difference especially on defence. 

Whilst it’s early days, this result could come back to bite the Cheetahs at the end of the season.

Bulls (19) – Lions (13)

The Lions are a side that are barely affected by losing players to the Springboks. It’ s an embarrassing place to be for a union that was South Africa’s team of the 90′s. They will only benefit from having a new coach, and more importantly by having the input of Mr Jake White!

The Lions started well and opened a 13-0 lead at halftime. However the Bulls showed they are a class side, have built a winning culture, and worked they way back into the match. It was mission accomplished, and now the youngsters have a chance to show what they can do. They just need to be there or thereabouts until the Boks come back, and then the Bulls are unstoppable!

Western Province (29) – Natal Sharks (15)

A smaller upset, and an indication that the Sharks may find this season tough trying to qualify for the semi-finals. Western Province find themselves in a position where they don’t have nearly as many Springboks as in the past, and this has allowed them strong continuity from the end of the Super 14.

The Sharks meanwhile have strangely already thrown up excuses, (they aren’t affected as strongly as the Bulls), and suffered the loss of Captain Johan Muller as well. For a side that lacks leadership, this may impact them the most.

Western Province now have an ideal opportunity to start stringing together some wins to put themselves in semi-final contention come the business end of the competition.

This weekend sees the Currie Cup for 2009 kick off.

Many of the fringe Springboks have been released back to their provinces to bolster their teams and the competition. Interestingly the Free State Cheetahs deemed Jongi Nokwe surplus to requirements. This is another example of the absurd thinking and behaviour that exists in South African rugby.

Here is my prediction for what I see happening in the Currie Cup 2009 (or what I hope happens anyway!)

1. Blue Bulls

Will be determined to add to their 2009 Super 14 victory and reclaim the Currie Cup which we have not held outright since 2004. We have the depth, the street smarts, and the winning habit which will allow us to grind out some valuable victories before the Springboks enter the fray. As long as we make the semis, our Boks will win us the Cup at the business end of the season.

2. Western Province

It’s been some lean years for Western Province at senior level. They haven’t seriously challenged for the Currie Cup since 2001, but they’ll be helped this season by the fact they don’t have too many Boks in their squad. This will ensure some continuity from their last couple of Super 14 games where they started to play to a winning pattern. I’m picking them to have a strong season and finish second.

3. Natal Sharks

The defending champions of the Currie Cup. They have a strong squad, but where they lack is in the key positions around number 8, flyhalf and inside centre. They have plenty of good players, but in the tighter games they’ll lack the leadership and decision making that comes from the 8-9-10-12 axis, and that will cost them.

4. Free State Cheetahs

Another side that is not affected greatly by losing players to the Springboks. Although they had a shocking Super 14 in 2009, they have performed strongly in the Currie Cup for the last 5 years. Unfortunately the 3 Springboks they lose are such a key to their performances. Captain fantastic Juan Smith leads from the front, and in Heinrich Brussow they lose their dominant factor at the breakdown. Jongi Nokwe is a lethal finisher, but seems to be out of favour. Will make the semis again, but at crunch time may struggle against the bigger guns.

5. Lions

Even the appointment of Jake White won’t be enough to save the Lions. They’ll look to build for next years Super 14, but have little chance in this years Currie Cup. They should get better as the tournament progresses, but end up on the receiving end of some large scores.

6. Griquas

Lack the depth and class to compete with the bigger unions, but always try hard and can surprise at home. They won the Vodacom cup this year and can never be taken lightly.

7. Boland

Have the ability to produce the odd upset at home but will do well to avoid relegation.

8. Platinum leopards

Will be fighting for survival all season long in this years Currie Cup premier division. Have some exciting players and could be entertaining if they can get enough ball.

Springbok Player ratings:

Props

The Beast – 6

Started off like a house on fire and got the better of Phil Vickery

John Smit – 8

Led from the front superbly and held his composure well. Always gave 100 percent effort, and his influence was noted when he left the field in Durban. He is the man to take us through to Rugby World Cup 2011. Whilst he’s always willing to carry the ball up, his only fault was not making it over the advantage line often enough. But all the Bok forwards suffered that problem.

Gurthro Steenkamp – 6

Made a vital turnover towards the end of the first test. Other than that he had very few opportunities and appears to be rated behind the Beast by de Villiers. His workrate and performances in the Super 14 were superb and probably deserves a starting position over the Beast, as he had no opportunity to show us what he can do against the British and Irish Lions.

Deon Carstens – 4

Was supposed to cover both sides of the scrum for the Boks, but his best move was getting injured in the first test to allow john Smit to come back on. I’m not convinced he is the player we need in the Boks, although he did have a good Super 14.

Hookers

Bismarck du Plessis – 5

Rated by some as the best hooker in South Africa because of his powerful scrumming, strong work in the set pieces and all round strength and ability. Whilst he can be great on his day, he had a quiet series and once again his poor discipline let the side down when he got frustrated in the third test. If we had a decent tighthead I’d move Smit back to hooker.

Chiliboy Ralepelle - 4

Clearly not the second best hooker in the country. Sure he has talent, but I am yet to see what his exceptional qualities are as he doesn’t dominate scrums, his lineout throwing is average and his work around the park is good, but doesn’t stand out. I’d have rated Derick Kuun as our second best hooker.

Locks

Bakkies Botha - 7

Once again Bakkies showed how important he is to the Springboks. He is the man we look to lead us into battle, and dominate the opposition pack. Had a solid series and was extremely unlucky to be suspended for doing nothing wrong. He is victimised, but he always seems to be in trouble! We don’t have another Bakkies anywhere, and we will need to start producing one soon, especially if Bakkies spends as much time off the field as he does on it!

Victor Matfield - 7

Whilst he didn’t do anything wrong other than 2 drop balls in the third test, Victor had a quiet series by his standards. He once again was a great, safe source of lineout ball, and did his works in the ruck.  However he wasn’t visible around the field as much as he usually is, and his role in dictating the play like he does at the Bulls was missing. Like all the Bulls players was strangely subdued and I don’t think that is any coincidence.

Andries Bekker – 5

Was a revelation last year, but is not the man to replace Bakkies as he is a lightweight. Good in the air, and quick around the field, but didn’t stand out for anything in particular. Almost cost the Boks the game at Loftus with his high tackle. Wouldn’t be in my Bok squad, and now appears quite injury prone.

Danie Rousouw – 4

Not a series to remember for the big man. Made minimal impact in Durban, and lasted about 2 minutes at Loftus. Is about the only lock we have to replace Bakkies, and is a strong ball carrier. I’d make him our lock replacement and not use him as a loose forward, where he lacks the necessary pace and athleticism.

Johan Muller - 4

Called in due to a Springbok locking crisis. A tough man who gives consistent effort, but not a world class lock. Did what one would expect, but not the man for the job. A better call may have been Steven Sykes.

Steven Sykes - 5

Didn’t get enough opportunity to evaluate his worth, but may be the longer term successor to Bakkies.

Loose Forwards

Heinrich Brussow - 7

Got around the field well and took his try superbly in the first test. Didn’t make any turnovers in the first test however he made some vital ones to help South Africa get back in the game at Loftus. At Ellis park  he was a mixed bag as he made some vital turnovers, allowed too many steals from the British and Irish Lions and started to lose his cool towards the end of the match. Is the only true opensider we have in our squad so we have to persist with him. Where are all our opensiders?

Juan Smith – 7

Worked tirelessly all series and has a high workrate. With ball in hand he couldn’t get over the advantage line often enough but was strong on defence. Appears to be slowing down a bit, but like the Bulls guys, doesn’t look like the same player who performs so strongly at Super 14 level.

Schalk Burger – 3 

Let the side and his reputation down with his despicable action at Loftus. The effects of his eye gouging will stay with him all career, and I wouldn’t be picking him based on his current form or behaviour. Has lost speed and fitness, and doesn’t throw himself around as he did a few years ago. Lacks accuracy in all he does although he appears to still retain enormous influence in the Bok squad. Disturbing to hear Peter de Villiers say he bases 60% of his game plan around Schalk. Maybe that’s why he had no plan B?

Pierre Spies – 6

Didn’t do anything wrong, but never stood out and for a world class player that’s not quite enough. He made a few good runs, and always looked strong with ball in hand, but when the Boks are struggling, he must gets the Boks going forward. Made a try saving tackle at the end of the first half at Loftus that had a huge bearing on the series. Needs to regain the spark he exhibited at the Bulls!

Ryan Kankowski - 4

Mr Show pony got a full game at Ellis Park in the third test. Not sure where he was hiding all game but he doesn’t do enough hard work when his team is on the back foot. I also think his handling skills aren’t good enough but he never got enough chances or went looking for work to show if that aspect of his game has improved or not. Would not be in my Springbok squad.

Halfbacks

Fourie Du Preez – 5

The best scrumhalf in the world was not involved heavily enough. Is capable of dictating games and with his boot he controls field position. His kicking through the whole series was not quite spot on, many of his kicks were too long. One could argue he didn’t get enough quality ball to stamp his authority on the series, but usually he makes his own opportunities. His covering of the oppositions long kicks was spot on at Loftus and it was his running back at the opposition that got the Boks on the front foot and eventually sealed the win.

Ricky Januarie – 3

 Out of form and a coaches selection. He let the side down in Durban and the criticism of his performance brought one of the strangest metaphors ever heard! Doesn’t deserve a spot ahead of Jano Vermaak.

Flyhalves

Ruan Pienaar – 6

Had a good game in Durban with his field kicking and place kicking being spot on. However he was under a lot more pressure at Loftus and failed that test dismally. Didn’t do much to dispell the opinion he blows hot or cold, but is still a tremendous talent. In the third test he played halfback, and his option taking was poor. Needs better direction, and either he or Morne Steyn need to be the Bok flyhalf for an extended period of time.

Morne Steyn - 9

Won the series for the Boks. Made a try saving tackle on Monye in the first test that went largely unnoticed. At Loftus he had a fairytale game, kicking everything from all around the park, ending with the perfectly scripted final kick from in his own half. Unfortunately in the third test he was unable to get a decent platform from his forward pack, but did his job adequately and kicked 100% once more.

Centres

Jean de Villiers – 6

Was finally able to play in an important series but had limited opportunities due to substitution and non-selection. Is one of the Bok playmakers but never given a chance to get into the game by coach Peter de Villiers. Needs to be more involved and more of our attck needs to based around him, as he takes the ball to the line strongly and creates opportunities for those around him.

Adi Jacobs – 5

Had  a poor series. On defence he was found out, and I don’t subscribe to the commonly held view that his defence has always been suspect. When fully fit he deserves his place in the starting lineup, but his shoulder is quite clearly not 100%. Was a revelation last year with his ability to test defences, and that aspect of his game has been missing since his injury. Someone please get him his surgery and the sooner we can get him back fully fit!

Jacque Fourie – 8

Took his chances beautifully at Loftus when it mattered. Other than that his defence and attacking game weren’t brilliant in the first and third tests. Is a great player, but not consistent enough to be rated as world class as many columnists in South Africa do. Could take a lesson from Brian O’Driscoll in that regard. A centre pairing of Jean de Villiers and Jacque Fourie in the tri-nations will be very solid.

Wynand Olivier – 4

Played his first test since 2007 and probably played his way out of the Bok starting team for a while again. I maintain that he is a good provincial player but not international class. He just doesn’t seem to do enough. He takes the ball to the line but never seems to break through or set anyone else up. Missed vital tackles in defence during the third test, and unfortunately threw the ball that Ugo Monye intercepted.

Wings

Bryan Habana – 7

Appears to be regaining the form of 2007, and took his try superbly at Loftus. Was involved more than he has been in the past, and his defence one on one remains strong, although he came off his wing that led to the Lions try at Loftus. Needs to be playing not resting on the sideline.

JP Pietersen – 7

Still a young player with much to offer South African rugby. It was good to see JP running with ball in hand and some space in both the tests he played in, but what was more impressive is his defence. He is very solid and makes some try saving tackles. In Durban he made some front on hits, on forwards that most international wingers wouldn’t make.  

Jongi Nokwe - 5

Only had the one chance and was never brought into the game. I maintain he is the quickest wing I’ve seen with a deadly step. Has the potential to be a match winner, but it not out there to simply make up the numbers, or get cold standing on the win. I’d love to see Habana and Nokwe as our wing combination, and then given space and ball to move in.

Odwa Ndungane - 6

Another player who is solid at provincial level, but not really world class. Lacks the pace of an international wing, but has a high workrate and goes looking for the ball. Can be prone to dropping the ball, but always gives 100% effort. Stole one ball in the tackle which was great work. I also think we have picked the wrong Ndungane, as Akona of the Bulls has better handling skills and is more consistent.

Fullbacks

Francois Steyn - 5

I won’t be disappointed to see Francois racing off to France, as I believe he is highly overrated. Francois showed once again that he lacks consistency. This was highlighted in his goalkicking. He strikes some kicks beautifully, whilst others he strikes light a 3rd grade club player. From the back his field kicking was poor. He had plenty of chances but generally kicked too deep, without putting any pressure on the back three of the Lions. For some reason he was moving backward in the Lions first tries at Durban and Loftus and this gave the Lions players space to create their tries. Had Francois moved forward, he’d have been able to cut down the space and may have stopped the Lions scoring those two tries.

Zane Kirchner -

The form fullback of the year in South Africa, was never in the squad early enough to make a telling contribution. Could have been the solidity at the back that the Boks needed, and his strength is that he puts up kicks and contests them. It would have been hugely unsettling to be called away from Bulls practice to the Bok squad, in the week leading up to his test debut, but I felt he performed adequately. Should be given the Bok fullback position for an extended run, as in my opinion he is a long term, world class prospect.

Coaches

Peter de Villiers - 2

Has the distinction of winning a series against the Lions, which no other coach in South Africa has achieved for a long time. However under de Villiers the Bokshave been extremely inconsistent, and he has taken a World Champion winning side and made some superstars look very average. It is disconcerting to see players that were performing at their peak capacity a month or so ago in the Super 14 suddenly struggling to hold their own. Almost all of the Bulls players have struggled in this series, which makes me believe that the coaching is the critical factor.

Great coaches get the best out of their players, and other than Australia at Ellis Park, and England at Twickenham, de Villiers has struggled to get this Bok side firing on all cylinders. Too often they look clueless, and not quite sure how to play. No gameplan seems apparent, and it is only the occasional brilliance of world class players that has ensured this Bok side has maintained a respectable record.

His public speaking and press conference ramblings are an embrassment to the team and the country, and it is high time someone made him pull his head in or resign.

Dick Muir and Gary Gold – 3

Neither the forward pack nor the backline seem to be playing to their potential, so both these guys should be booted out along with de Villiers. One can see the influence of Muir and Gold, especially in the backline where no specialist fullback was initially picked. Muir has always favoured versatility, yet hasn’t won anything of substance with his approach.

I favour a clean out of the entire coaching staff.

A 2-1 series win to the Springboks over the British and Irish Lions avenged the disappointment of 1997 .

In many ways however this series failed to live up to expectation, was blighted by off the ball incidents and was littered with inconsistent officiating.

The Springboks seem to be very happy and satisfied with a 2-1 series win, even though they were disgraceful in the 3rd test. The bad memories of 1997 can now be replaced by a series win, and it is eerie how similar the 2009 campaign was to 1997, with the roles reversed.

In 1997 the Boks were clearly the better side, and outscored the Lions by 9 tries to 3. However poor goalkicking let them down and the Lions managed to win the first 2 games even though they were outplayed. The series win was sealed with a Jeremy Guscott drop goal. In the dead rubber, the Springboks won by 19 points.

In 2009, the Springboks won the first test albeit unconvincingly, won the second even thought they were outplayed for a lot of it, and sneaked home courtesy of better goalkicking and a hero in Morne Steyn. And in the dead rubber they were beaten by 19 points.

The First test started off with the Springboks looking extremely focused and professional. They played the sort of rugby that won them the Rugby World Cup in 2007, dominate the set pieces, kick the goals and make no errors. It is not pretty rugby, but it can be mighty effective in tight contests. The Lions meanwhile looked to play the more expansive game, on the hard fields of South Africa.

It was the Springboks though who dominated the first 60 minutes, sticking to the pattern they know best. With a 19 point lead, the game was effectively sealed. However a mass substitution strategy by coach Peter de Villiers robbed the Boks of their momentum and the Lions sniffed an opening. They showed great composure and determination to stick to their running game and the Boks simply held on for dear life. The reintroduction of John Smit with a few minutes left was imperative to regain composure, play the percentages and grind out the victory.

It showed that although the Boks could seemingly destroy this Lions side by playing their game, any let up would be punished. The Lions meanwhile were willing to take greater risks and try and expose the Springbok defence out wide.

A tough Itinerary for the Lions saw them based in Capetown for the week leading up to the test at Loftus Versfeld in Pretoria. The Boks meanwhile had the luxury of getting accustomed to the highveld. It was meant to mean a hiding for the Lions in the last 2 weeks of a tough tour. Instead we saw 2 shocking Boks performances.

Schalk Burger let himself down and will have to deal with a tarnished reputation for the rest of his life. The Lions seized their chance and started exposing the Springbok defence almost at will. The Boks looked shocked and simply could not construct any sort of phase play. facing an 8 point deficit at halftime, the Boks played their second best half of the series. They got field position and ran the ball back at the Lions, forcing errors and working 2 more wonderful tries.

It took some brilliance from Jacque Fourie, a moment of madness from Ronan O’Gara and up stepped Steyn to do to the Lions what Guscott had done to the Boks in 1997. It wasn’t fair, but it lasts for 12 painful years.

The dead rubber at Ellis park was all about pride for the Lions, and a chance for many Boks to earn a place in the ‘first’ team. The Lions were magnificent, and once again employed the same strategy as they employed all tour, despite having massive personnel changes.

I liked the way they moved the ball, ran straight and hard, and took the ball through phases. Many in the Southern hempisherecriticize players like Stephen Jones as one dimensional, but he was instrumental in dictating the way the Lions played, and was prominent looping around the outside backs to create the extra man.

The Boks meanwhile looked devoid of any sense of a game plan other than to play error free rugby in the opposition half, and feed off the Lions mistakes. Their runners were unable to break the advantage line, meaning we often resorted to kicking, which was aimless from the back. The Lions returned the ball with interest from Rob Kearney and Jones.

Whilst I thought the Lions got away with a lot of negative play at the breakdown, especially in the third test, they played to the referee and got away with it. The fact they transgressed the offside line stopped the Boks getting over the advantage line and the Boks were either too shallow turning the ball over, or too deep and nailed behind the advantage line.

No one in the Springbok side was able to produce any tactic to overcome this. It may be why the Boks had greater success from set pieces in scoring tries. However it was interesting how the Bulls players who played so well a month or so ago, and a team that are full of World Class players, now look very average. I think much blame has to go to the coaching staff, especially madmad Peter de Villers! He has not produced anything constructive from the Boks, we were outscored in the series 74-63, but more importantly the Lions scored 7 tries to our 5.

Whilst we may have won the series 2-1, the Lions can claim the moral victory as we did in 1997. Whilst we have 12 years to claim the result, we have 12 more years of waiting to stamp our dominance over the Lions…

Check out my Springbok player ratings for the British and Irish Lions series

This was a shocking team effort from the Springbok, who let themselves, the country and the jersey down. Individually it was hard to find huge fault, but collectively they were awful. Inconsistency is the only consistency since de Villiers became coach and he has taken a World Champion side with awesome players, into an average side.

Springbok Player ratings:

1. The Beast – 6

Since the first test his scrumming has gone downhill. Also in the loose he was not prominent and like all the other Springbok forwards, couldn’t manage to get over the advantage line. Has to start performing every game.

2. Chiliboy Ralepelle - 5

His scrumming, lineout throwing and general play around the field aren’t exceptional, which all the duties he is selected for! Quite clearly not the number 2 hooker in world rugby, and it hasn’t helped him to be given an honourary place on the Springbok side.

3. John Smit – 7

Always leads from the front. Not making enough yardage with bal in hand but controls the side as well as any captain could. A brave player, and if there were any decent tightheads available for the Boks, I’d move him back to hooker.

4. Johan Muller - 5

Another brave player but is limited in capacity. Never gives up, but just not worthy of playing at this high a level. Where are these 10 locks de Villiers says we have capable of playing at this level?

5. Victor Matfield – 6

Victor hasn’t quite been himself this series. Like all the Bulls guys, something has gone seriously wrong since winning the Super 14. Is it the coach, the environment or what?? Also dropped 2 balls, quite unlike Big Vic. Still a world class player.

6. Heinrich Brussow - 5

Got a couple of turnovers, but lacked prsence at the breakdown. Martyn Williams got the better of him, and that resulted in points for the Lions. Heinrich also got frustrated towards the end of the game too. South Africa needs a bigger, more aggressive opensider.

7. Juan Smith -7

Worked tirelessly all game, and used a lot as a ball carrier. Still not sure why he hasn’t been breaking the advantage line very often. Made plenty of tackles too.

8. Ryan Kankowski - 4

Not quite sure where Kankowski was playing. A couple of times he showed up at Ellis Park but didn’t do anything spectacular. If Spies is the devastating runner, we need  a more direct number 8 as backup.

9. Fourie Du Preez – 5

Like big Vic, Fourie has not enjoyed the Springbok setup. His box kicks haven’t been accurate, but his covering play has still been first class. Needs to get better protection at the rucks so he can clear ball faster.

10. Morne Steyn - 6

Kicked 3 from 3, but couldn’t dictate play because of poor quality ball. Didn everything he could, but his teammates need to help him out.

11. Jongi Nokwe - 5

Play never ran his way and he picked up a dislocated finger after which he was tentative. Could look for more work, but when you have a matchwinner like Jongi in your side, use him! A strange decision to replace him with Spies.

12. Wynand Olivier - 4

I’ve never thought Wynand Olivier is world class and Springbok level despite his good Super 14 form. Doesn’t get through many gaps and set others up, but runs straight and hard and does his job. Missed an important tackle and threw the ball that gifted Monye a try. A day to forget.

13. Jacque Fourie - 6

Had a chance to show everyone why he is highly rated. Didn’t do anything spectaular, and his defence is not rock solid as many think it is. Solid game, but a fully fit Adi Jacobs is still my first choice.

14. Odwa Ndungane - 6

Didn’t too much wrong, and got a valuable steal. However the Lions attacked down his side at every chance and that’s where they made inroads. May have been the people inside him that were more responsible however. Not enough pace to be world class.

15. Zane Kirchner - 7

Didn’t do much wrong, but wasn’t helped out by his teammates. A couple of errors including a left footed kick out on the full, but deserves another chance. Why was he subbed so early? What was the point of giving him the starting position?

16. Bismarck du Plessis - 6

Solid in the set pieces but once again his temper got the better of him when the game was getting away from the Springboks. Would still be my reserve hooker, with Smit starting.

17. Gurthro Steenkamp -

Not on long enough to make a good assessment.

18. Deon Carstens -

Did not play

19. Steven Sykes -

Not on long enough to make a good assessment.

20. Pierre Spies - 6

Made a couple of runs, nothing spectacular. Bizarre move to bring him on at wing.

21. Ruan Pienaar - 5

Rusty as a scrumhalf. Was clearly feeling the pressure to do something spectacular in the second half anf took the wrong option a couple of times.

22. Francois Steyn – 5

Many were pleased with his effort, but he didn’t do anything spectacular. One dimensional in running with ball and simply tries to run over players. A predictable player who lacks accuracy.